FULL STORY

Stanford Professor's Peer-Review Prediction Sparks Debate

Stanford's Anshul Kundaje predicted a radical shift in scientific outputs and peer review within five years, then debated its abolition and reform with peers, advocating open review to counter reviewer bullying.

2026-11-18 ~ 2026-11-19 · 3 episodes · 17 posts

Episode 1 · Stanford Professor Predicts Peer Review Will Become a Farce Within Five Years (2026-11-18, 2 posts)

Stanford professor Anshul Kundaje predicts that scientific deliverables will diversify dramatically within five years, while the cost-benefit ratio of gatekeeping peer review will rise super-exponentially, rendering it a farce. A Stanford biomedical researcher echoed the prediction.

Episode 2 · Stanford professor sparks debate on whether most science needs peer review at all (2026-11-19, 13 posts)

On November 19, Stanford professor Anshul Kundaje engaged in an extended discussion on X with computational biologist Sasha Gusev and others over whether peer review should be abolished or reformed. Kundaje's core claim: most scientific output is inconsequential in terms of broad impact and doesn't urgently need peer review; as long as content can reach interested readers through multiple channels, the community will naturally read, assess, and comment on it—and this organic process shouldn't be replaced by artificially mandated review.

Confirmed

  • Kundaje put forward multiple reform proposals: don't force anyone to review, since mandatory reviewing is the root cause of mismatched expertise, perfunctory reviews, and outsourcing to AI; support "piece-wise review," letting people with genuine expertise or interest review only the parts they care about; alternative incentive structures for reviewing could be designed, but need buy-in from "those in power," while journals and their interest groups will fight such changes tooth and nail; validity certification needn't go through journals or figurehead editors, and peer review shouldn't use public funds to sustain publishers; he also suggested using AI to save reviewing time and return scholarly commentary to organic discussion.
  • Gusev and Kundaje discussed an alternative definition of peer review: multiple people carefully reading a manuscript and providing detailed feedback, with authors having some obligation to respond. Kundaje accepted this definition, provided there are no gatekeeping thresholds and no requirement to respond to every comment.
  • Gusev's position: while the value doesn't lie in journals themselves, the journal system creates reviewing incentives that are hard to replicate—authors who serve as reviewers at journals they've published in genuinely uphold standards; if anonymous review were to actually work, you'd need a third party tracking reviewers and infrastructure driving reviews and author responses, "which is basically a journal"—hence he favors open review over anonymous review, arguing that making it public is the best adversarial step.
  • Computational biologist Jacob Schreiber raised a pointed challenge: why should a reviewer who spends a few hours reading a manuscript be more entitled than the lab itself to decide the direction of months of its work? He welcomed feedback but said responding to clearly off-base opinions is a waste of time.

Why it matters

  • The dispute strikes at the core contradiction of academic publishing: peer review's legitimacy derives from journal incentives, yet the journal system is accused of being sustained by public funds and blocking alternatives—reform must tackle incentives and institutional power simultaneously.
  • Concrete proposals surfaced in the discussion—piece-wise review, open review, AI-assisted reviewing—offer discussable paths for reforming academic publishing, while also exposing a fundamental disagreement over where accountability lies: whether authors are obligated to respond to feedback.

Episode 3 · Stanford Professor on Reviewer Bullying: Public Exposure Plus Senior Protection (2026-11-19, 2 posts)

Stanford professor Anshul Kundaje says reviewer bullying in academia has worsened, arguing that victims should publicly expose retaliatory reviews while senior scientists collectively protect them, though he admits this mechanism carries high costs.