Researchers Debate Why Journal Peer Review's Incentives Are Hard to Replace

SashaGusevPosts · x · 2026-11-19

Computational biologist Sasha Gusev argues the value of peer review isn't in journals themselves but in the incentive structure they create: authors feel obligated to review for journals they published in, and take it seriously to avoid devaluing their own prior work — imperfect but partially aligned incentives. Anshul Kundaje pushes for gatekeeping-free alternatives that don't rely on journals, named editors, or three anointed reviewers, adding that any replacement needs approval from the powers that be for adoption, and journals will fight tooth and nail to prevent it.

Related event: Stanford professor sparks debate on whether most science needs peer review at all(13 posts)→

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →