Sasha Gusev argues open critiques beat anonymous peer review as the best adversarial step

SashaGusevPosts · x · 2026-11-19

Geneticist Sasha Gusev debates peer-review reform with Anshul Kundaje. He questions how anonymous review can be enforced: it requires an impartial third party to track reviewers plus infrastructure to push reviews and responses — "at that point you basically have a journal."

He argues for a soft adversarial step where reviewers raise concerns and authors feel some pressure to respond, because authors develop blind spots, and because addressing reviewer concerns increases other readers' confidence even if the authors disagree. Kundaje adds: the best adversarial step is publishing critiques openly, with attribution or anonymously, letting the community weigh in.

Related event: Stanford professor sparks debate on whether most science needs peer review at all(13 posts)→

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →