Anshul Kundaje proposes piece-wise peer review: experts weigh in only on what they know

anshulkundaje · x · 2026-11-19

Stanford professor Anshul Kundaje continues his peer-review reform argument: nobody should be forced to review — mandatory review causes mismatched expertise, shoddy reviews from disinterested parties, and AI shortcuts to just get it done. Feedback should come from genuinely interested parties with relevant expertise.

He proposes piece-wise feedback: why must one person review an entire paper rather than pointing out the one or two things they really care about and know? Review infrastructure should make both whole-artifact and piece-wise feedback easy, with people participating because they deeply care about their domain and agree or disagree with each other.

Related event: Stanford professor sparks debate on whether most science needs peer review at all(11 posts)→

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →