Should reviewers steer a lab's agenda? Gusev defends soft adversarial peer review

SashaGusevPosts · x · 2026-11-19

In an ongoing peer-review debate, jmschreiber91 asks pointedly: why should authors be obligated to address feedback — how can a reviewer's few hours direct another lab's effort better than the lab itself deciding what to work on next?

Sasha Gusev responds that labs can always dismiss feedback or withdraw and resubmit elsewhere, but a soft adversarial step still has value: authors develop blind spots around their own work and miss weaknesses that reveal flaws; and reviewers represent a non-negligible segment of readers, so addressing concerns increases other readers' confidence in the findings.

Related event: Stanford professor sparks debate on whether most science needs peer review at all(13 posts)→

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →