FULL STORY
ICLR's Peer-Review Crisis: Silent Reviewers and Withdrawal Disputes
ICLR authors report reviewers going silent after rebuttals and scores barely changing, while a wave of withdrawals over poor reviews sparked fresh disputes, fueling broad criticism of the conference's peer review.
2026-11-16 ~ 2026-11-20 · 3 episodes · 7 posts
Episode 1 · ICLR Review Woes: Rebuttals Go Unanswered as Authors and ACs Complain (2026-11-16, 2 posts)
ICLR's peer review process is under fire: an Area Chair asked how to handle a paper whose rebuttal received no reviewer responses, while an ICLR 2027 author complained of getting only a dismissive reply right before the rebuttal deadline.
- ICLR 2027 author gets "you didn't address my concern" one day before the rebuttal deadline — 3scorciav · 2026-11-16
- ICLR AC asks what to do when reviewers ignore a strong rebuttal on a borderline paper — Entity303BR · 2026-11-18
Episode 2 · ICLR Authors Vent as Reviewers Go Silent After Rebuttals (2026-11-19, 3 posts)
ICLR authors report reviewers going completely silent after detailed rebuttals and supplementary experiments, with scores unchanged despite two weeks of effort, sparking complaints about the review process.
- ICLR authors get zero reviewer responses to rebuttal with scores 3,3,2 — pastaHacker · 2026-11-19
- Two weeks of ICLR rebuttal work, zero review scores changed — aran_nayebi · 2026-11-20
- ICLR reviewers go silent after rebuttal, author begs AC for help — Alternative_Art2984 · 2026-11-20
Episode 3 · ICLR Author's 40-Page Rebuttal Gets No Reviewer Response (2026-11-19, 2 posts)
Amid controversy over authors withdrawing ICLR papers after poor reviews, one author says his 40-page rebuttal received no reviewer response during the discussion period, raising questions about how common such silence is and whether ACs will intervene.
- ICLR author expands rebuttal from 24 to 40 pages, gets zero reviewer replies — O_Fake_One · 2026-11-19
- Author fires back at ICLR withdrawal backlash: rebuttal got zero responses — hbouammar · 2026-11-19