Author fires back at ICLR withdrawal backlash: rebuttal got zero responses
hbouammar · x · 2026-11-19
Amid controversy over authors withdrawing ICLR papers after bad reviews, one author pushes back publicly: they chose not to withdraw, wrote a huge rebuttal instead — and received no responses from reviewers. The author asks whether ACs, PCs and reviewers appalled by withdrawals are equally appalled by silent rebuttals, questioning the point of the whole exercise. The post highlights the trust breakdown in top-conference reviewing: withdrawals are frowned upon while the rebuttal process can go unanswered.
More from Research
- Sandia Labs' VASt model predicts high-entropy alloy properties from tens of samples — CurieuxExplorer · 2026-11-19
- FoodTruck Bench, an LLM agent business-sim benchmark, lands on Papers with Code — NielsRogge · 2026-11-19
- MIT reads and steers LLMs' internal physics intuition via hidden-state shifts in Gemma — ProfBuehlerMIT · 2026-11-19
- harness-hub open-sources RL-trained LoRA adapters tuned per agent harness, recipe coming Friday — yb2698 · 2026-11-19
- Freenet releases new video on network routing with old-school ML — Sanity · 2026-11-19
- Empire AI creates 120+ early-career research positions in New York, Cornell deadline Dec 15 — dianarycai · 2026-11-19