ICLR AC asks what to do when reviewers ignore a strong rebuttal on a borderline paper

Entity303BR · reddit · 2026-11-18

An ICLR Area Chair asks on Reddit how to handle a borderline paper (2/2/3) whose authors submitted a strong rebuttal directly addressing every concern — yet none of the reviewers responded or updated their scores. How much should the rebuttal weigh when no one engages with it?

The poster adds that one of the 2-scores appears to be an AI-generated review listing entirely hallucinated issues, fueling discussion about reviewer negligence and AI creeping into peer review.

Related event: ICLR Review Woes: Rebuttals Go Unanswered as Authors and ACs Complain(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →