Matthew Green highlights unexplained skipped curves in NIST P-256/P-224 seed generation

matthew_d_green · x · 2026-10-17

Cryptographer Matthew Green shares the open questions from an analysis of NIST elliptic curve generation: not every 20-byte candidate seed yields a viable curve, and some viable curves were skipped. P-256's published seed is candidate 1842, but candidate 876 from the same run also produces a prime-order curve with parameters chosen the same way; P-224's run passed over three such curves and the two runs behind the ANSI X9.62 example curves skipped seven more. The criteria used — or whether this was unintentional — remain unknown.

Original post →

More from Safety

Safety channel →