ICLR Reviewer Advises Authors on Handling Nitpicking and AI Reviews

An ICLR reviewer advises authors to counter nitpicking by quoting reviewers' exact words point-by-point and escalating to the AC when warranted, while noting that even flawed AI reviews can raise legitimate issues, such as missing confidence intervals, that deserve serious rebuttal.

2026-11-07 ~ 2026-11-07 · 2 related posts

• ICLR authors: rebut nitpicking reviewers by quoting their exact claims — brunofmr · 2026-11-07
• ICLR reviewer: AI-flagged missing confidence intervals is a real problem — brunofmr · 2026-11-07