ICLR debate: cap author rebuttals — and reviewers' 32 AI-generated weaknesses too?
TuhinChakr · x · 2026-11-19
A debate over ICLR review norms: weilunchao argues the conference should cap author rebuttals, since a paper needing an extremely long rebuttal 'just means it's not ready,' and lengthy rebuttals tempt reviewers to use 'tools' to cope. TuhinChakr raises the symmetric problem: should reviewers also be limited from dumping 32 AI-generated weaknesses? The thread highlights how rebuttal arms races and AI-generated reviews are feeding each other in peer review.
More from Research
- "There is no science of transformers" — researcher slams irreproducible AI research — gerardsans · 2026-11-19
- The Little Book of ML Metrics nears launch, pre-order at $60 for data scientists — santiviquez · 2026-11-19
- Schmidhuber publishes annotated AI history tracing deep learning to 1676 — SchmidhuberAI · 2026-11-19
- Weight-space blend of base and RL checkpoints restores the diversity RL removed: α=0.25 keeps 64-80% of pass@1 gain — Perfect_Power815 · 2026-11-19
- Erik Hoel: consciousness is a great mystery, but its definition isn't — experts largely agree — koltregaskes · 2026-11-19
- ICLR author expands rebuttal from 24 to 40 pages, gets zero reviewer replies — O_Fake_One · 2026-11-19