Erik Hoel: consciousness is a great mystery, but its definition isn't — experts largely agree
koltregaskes · x · 2026-11-19
Erik Hoel pushes back on the persistent myth that "consciousness" is too slippery to even define, let alone study.
Key points:
- The "argument from undefinability" shows up often among people with CS/math/cog-sci backgrounds; a LessWrong survey found them conflating consciousness with introspection, purposefulness, pleasure/pain, and intelligence — a confusion especially prominent among AI researchers
- In reality, experts who actually research or write about consciousness broadly agree on the linguistic definition; the undefinability objection is usually a rhetorical move to delegitimize the field
His framing: consciousness as a phenomenon is a deep mystery, but the word's definition isn't — real debates happen above the definitional layer.
Related event: Neuroscientist Erik Hoel Debunks the "Consciousness Is Undefinable" Myth(2 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- AI safety researcher: frontier training needs government shutdown capability, current models already unmanaged — davidmanheim · 2026-11-19
- AI safety researcher: governments must be able to monitor and halt frontier training — davidmanheim · 2026-11-19
- UK tech figure slams defeatism on homegrown frontier models: 'We must be mad not to try' — rosstaylor90 · 2026-11-19
- Keynes' 1930 warning on technological unemployment is landing right on schedule — tobowers · 2026-11-19
- Researcher defends Anthropic: any careful game-out of the dynamics points its way — AaronBergman18 · 2026-11-19
- Prediction: in 20 years no one will use non-personalized UIs — StewartalsopIII · 2026-11-19