AI hit 55% median accuracy on real QuickBooks month-end checks — guardrails, not prompts, fixed it

Samtyang · reddit · 2026-11-13

A developer building accounting automation for trade contractors tested frontier and open-weight models unassisted on real anonymized QuickBooks month-end close checks: median raw accuracy was 55%, with subtle handoff traps (stale invoice totals, unlabeled supplier bills auto-coded to overhead, deferred-vs-recognized revenue confusion) rather than wild hallucinations. Prompt tweaks barely helped; what worked was moving math and permissions out of the prompt — code verifying every dollar figure against underlying workpapers, read-only analysis with staged proposed entries showing before/after balances, and human approval plus live read-back checks before anything touches the ledger. The author solicits other production-grade hard stops from ERP/field-service agent builders.

Original post →

More from coding & agent

coding & agent channel →