Workshop repo: when to use Claude Skills vs MCP tools vs agent definitions

cfregly · x · 2026-11-01

cfregly's learn-claude-workshop repo offers a practical chooser for Skill/Tool/MCP/agent-definition layers, demoed on a fictional Northstar Freight renewal-brief task. Key tradeoffs: custom Skills reuse know-how but need upkeep; MCP connects tools but needs access and failure handling; agent definitions reuse worker settings but still need review; sometimes a plain script suffices. The repo includes an MCP server with denial checks, a Skills API bundle pinned by version, a bundled self-checking renderer, and a local evidence checker comparing tool results, file hashes and outputs.

Related event: Claude Workshop Offers Layered Guidance on Choosing Skills, MCP and Agents(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from coding & agent

coding & agent channel →