Why are some GPT-5 API requests costing 3x more? Hidden reasoning tokens suspected

Swimming-Skirt3870 · reddit · 2026-10-24

A developer processing documents with the GPT-5 API noticed identical-length documents costing 2-3x more per request. Input size doesn't explain it — some requests burn far more output tokens, likely hidden reasoning tokens rather than the actual response. This makes batch cost estimation unreliable. They ask how production users separately track reasoning vs. response tokens to audit per-request cost.

Original post →

More from Models

Models channel →