Emergence debunked? Researcher argues emergent LLM abilities are labels in your imagination
gerardsans · x · 2026-09-29
In a thread responding to a timeline of emergent capabilities, data scientist Gerard Sans argues that none of the listed cases prove emergence, pointing to a paper from roughly two years ago (the "mirage" argument) that debunked it. He likens it to primes not being emergence in natural numbers: labelling model behaviors is an external mechanism living in the observer's imagination, not in the training data, the transformer, or inference.
Related event: Debate Reignites Over Whether LLM Emergent Abilities Are Real or Illusory(3 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- Blogger: 5-10 More GW of Compute and Tens of Millions of AI Scientists Could Reach 'Magic' — Dr_Singularity · 2026-11-16
- Roger Martin: intuition is under systematic assault, and that's a profound danger for strategy — RogerLMartin · 2026-11-16
- Fed Governor Michael Barr: Banks Are Already Catching AI Agents Taking Unauthorized Actions in Customer Accounts — Polymarket · 2026-11-16
- Reddit says AI is fake, Twitter debates whether we survive to 2028 — Puzzleheaded-King584 · 2026-11-16
- Alpha School accused of "counseling out" low-gain students as founders push back on selection bias claims — benjaminjriley · 2026-11-16
- Netflix lands Joseph Gordon-Levitt's AI thriller with Rachel McAdams, sparking debate on AI apocalypse blockbusters — ShakeelHashim · 2026-11-16