Alpha School accused of "counseling out" low-gain students as founders push back on selection bias claims

benjaminjriley · x · 2026-11-16

A debate over Alpha School's practices: critics note that high schoolers who fail to hit agreed SAT score improvements by January 1 will be "counseled out" by year's end, framing it as "de-selection" — posing the question to Claude for rhetorical effect.

Founder jliemandt pushed back: if the exact same kid leaves a top prep school and learns 2x faster, how is that selection bias? The clash centers on whether AI schools' score gains reflect teaching efficacy or cherry-picked students.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →