Microsoft's AI-consciousness stance called incoherent, traced back to Suleyman's 'seemingly conscious AI' post
rgblong · x · 2026-09-15
Microsoft AI firmly holds that AI is not conscious while also saying the science of AI consciousness "is far from settled." Commentator camhberg points out that by its own logic the position is unscientific and premature: either "the science needs to get done," or "nothing to see here, I'm sure" — not both.
rgblong traces the incoherence to Mustafa Suleyman's 'Seemingly conscious AI' post last year and distills it into a syllogism: 1) we can't definitively say AI isn't conscious; 2) it's dangerous for others to think it is; 3) therefore AI is definitely not conscious. A substantive clash over big-lab consciousness rhetoric.
Related event: Microsoft's "AI is not conscious" stance criticized as self-contradictory(7 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- Kevin Roose's Machine Gods pod: why scientists are mad at OpenAI solving their hardest problems — kevinroose · 2026-10-30
- Cryptographer Matthew Green: Anthropic's agent worm framing is unhelpful, we need a simulated one to know — matthew_d_green · 2026-10-30
- Ethan Mollick on AI and work: 'You're a hand-weaver in a world of power looms' — emollick · 2026-10-30
- Vercel founder Rauch: trust is the deepest moat for a post-AGI business — soleio · 2026-10-30
- Scattered Across AI Assistants: A New Kind of Cognitive Failure Nobody Has a Prior For — manosaie · 2026-10-30
- a16z partners: 10-20M people drive $150-200B in token spend, and AI workspaces will eat the browser — petergyang · 2026-10-30