Embodiment doesn't vanish above low-level controllers — the Isola assumption is unproven
GeorgiaChal · x · 2026-09-08
Georgia Chalenti joined the Malik–Isola embodied-AI debate: she agrees hierarchy is an old idea in robotics and behavior systems, but embodiment doesn't disappear above the low-level controller. High-level reasoning still must adapt to what's physically plausible for a specific body, environment, and interaction — whether via persistent memory, online adaptation, or post-training remains open.
Her key rebuttal to Isola: assuming coding/VLM agents already possess this competence simply because humans supplied the right priors, tools, and abstractions is not demonstrated.
Related event: Embodied AI debate escalates as Isola and Chalenti respond to Malik(2 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- US chases AGI dominance while China, EU and ASEAN treat AI as public infrastructure — BubblyExtent1693 · 2026-10-27
- Lab monkeys at $30-80K each: a 4-year breeding cycle is the real preclinical drug bottleneck — zebird0 · 2026-10-27
- CJR: journalists should stop hyping AI's supposed humanity — just say 'rogue' — ShakeelHashim · 2026-10-27
- PhD applicant emails up 4x YoY due to AI — writing without AI now makes you stand out — AI4Code · 2026-10-27
- Weil's collapse shows BigLaw dies from eroding belief, not a broken business model — jkubicki · 2026-10-27
- All 8 Transformer paper authors left Google, and rival labs captured most of the frontier value — signulll · 2026-10-27