Heavy User's Early Review of Astra (GPT-6): High Intelligence, Low Intuition
ZenenoDev · reddit · 2026-09-05
A developer who heavily uses both Claude and Codex shared first-day impressions of Astra (GPT-6): "high intelligence, low intuition."
Key observations:
- The author builds complex orchestration/workflow systems where understanding existing architecture and intent matters as much as writing good code.
- Astra showed genuinely new capability: clever solution moves other models hadn't attempted.
- But roughly 4 times in a few hours (across separate chats) it missed intent: given an existing browser-based preview system plus docs, it proposed unnecessary new browser infrastructure and Cloudflare integrations without explaining why the existing system fell short.
- Worse, it picked an approach and started implementing before agreeing on direction; Codex's Sol 5.6 would inspect docs, explain its plan, and leave room to clarify.
Verdict: Gains in coding ability came with a less consistent collaborative experience. The overhead of redirecting it has the author considering switching back to Sol—unusual for someone who prefers newer models. Understanding constraints, scoping solutions, and communicating plans are part of technical capability, and the author hopes OpenAI addresses them.
More from coding & agent
- Redditor builds free AskSary creative studio with game engine GPT can play and patch live — Beneficial-Cow-7408 · 2026-09-06
- Do the fun terminal work yourself, let Claude handle the boring chores — 4310sy · 2026-09-06
- Heavy AI user's cost ledger: 100+ agents a day, $70 of DeepSeek in two days — simmon_charlie · 2026-09-06
- First untrained agent run on local Qwen 3.8 Flash, no skills configured — jasonkneen · 2026-09-06
- Is a schema-aware memory graph 'overfitting'? Dev asks for the cleanest leakage test — chaachans · 2026-09-06
- Redditor uses coding agent to finish an obscure 18xx Pennsylvania railroad game — natep1098 · 2026-09-06