NUS Law Professor Chesterman: Era of AI Self-Governance Is Over, Singapore Can Broker Trust
On September 28, NUS law professor Simon Chesterman published a thread laying out his case for AI governance, concluding that "the days of letting new silicon sovereigns govern themselves are over." The thread accompanies his article "Silicon Sovereigns: Artificial Intelligence, International Law, and the Tech-Industrial Complex" in a special issue of the American Journal of International Law (AJIL), Volume 120.
Confirmed
- Chesterman argues that AI systems are increasingly capable and their harms no longer stay in the digital world, with growing real-world consequences.
- Even if one trusted frontier AI companies to do the right thing, recent events have exposed the limits of voluntary self-regulation, and increasingly autonomous systems are harder to evaluate and constrain.
- Invoking the "Butlerian Jihad" from Dune, he notes that simply banning AI is not viable in reality, so states need real domestic regulation and at minimum international coordination.
- For coordination, he proposes drawing on institutions like the IAEA—not to liken AI to nuclear technology, but because real international institutions can build shared expectations, facilitate information sharing, and provide verification mechanisms.
- He also casts Singapore in a special role: it will not lead frontier AI, but it can offer an increasingly scarce resource—trust—given its highly educated, hyper-connected society and deep cultural and economic ties to both dominant AI powers, making it a potential middleman in international AI governance.
Why it matters
- Borrowing the bureaucratic adage "never waste a good crisis," Chesterman suggests that if recent AI crises are serious enough, they may drive substantive action—otherwise the world may wait for something worse. His thread offers a concrete path from talk to action for international AI governance, and positions Singapore as a potential coordinator.
2026-09-28 ~ 2026-09-28 · 9 related posts
Primary sources
- "The days of letting our silicon sovereigns govern themselves are over" — ProfChesterman ·
- Chesterman's AJIL essay "Silicon Sovereigns": AI, international law, and the tech-industrial complex — ProfChesterman ·
- AI law scholar Chesterman: don't waste a crisis to rein in self-governing AI — ProfChesterman ·
- [source] "The days of letting our silicon sovereigns govern themselves are over" — ProfChesterman · 2026-09-28
- AI harms are no longer confined to the digital world, Chesterman warns — ProfChesterman · 2026-09-28
- Voluntary AI self-regulation has hit its limits, argues Chesterman — ProfChesterman · 2026-09-28
- Singapore's unusual position: strong ties to both leading AI powers — ProfChesterman · 2026-09-28
- No Butlerian Jihad: Chesterman calls for national AI regulation and international coordination — ProfChesterman · 2026-09-28
- Chesterman: the IAEA model shows how international institutions could govern AI — ProfChesterman · 2026-09-28
- Singapore can offer AI governance something scarce: trust, says Chesterman — ProfChesterman · 2026-09-28
- [source] AI law scholar Chesterman: don't waste a crisis to rein in self-governing AI — ProfChesterman · 2026-09-28
- [source] Chesterman's AJIL essay "Silicon Sovereigns": AI, international law, and the tech-industrial complex — ProfChesterman · 2026-09-28