Cutting MCP tools from 7 to 2: 7% cheaper API calls but 18% more tokens

Independent-Flow3408 · reddit · 2026-11-23

The author of SigMap, an open-source repository navigation MCP server, trimmed its tool surface for code-location tasks from seven tools to two (querycontext and getlines), dropping impact analysis, callees, and verification. In a held-out 20-repo agent study (Messages API, Haiku 5.5), the lean setup cut API cost 7% (95% CI -13%-2%) while time stayed flat (+1%) and total tokens grew 18%. Token accounting: 426 tool-definition tokens per turn for locate vs 1505 for core. The author cautions two tools aren't always better — editing-and-verify workflows may need the removed tools — and asks other MCP builders whether they ship broad toolsets, task-specific profiles, or dynamic discovery. The attached screenshot shows SigMap's GitHub page (97% token reduction, 38 languages).

Original post →

More from coding & agent

coding & agent channel →