AI finds formal flaws in top economics papers, echoing long-standing critiques
elonmusk · x · 2026-11-23
The core story: The Economist reports that AI has found many top economics papers to be formally flawed — a claim physicist Ole Peters amplified, noting he'd argued the same for years without AI's help.
The specifics:
- Peters points to Bernoulli's 1738 error on expected utility, which he says persisted uncorrected into the 20th century
- He argues Menger's 1934 work is therefore invalid, and that the journal involved declined to publish a correction when he contacted them
- He extends the critique to Kahneman & Tversky's foundational Prospect Theory paper, calling its definition of expected-utility theory mathematically implausible
- Quoted economist Emanuel Derman adds that his 2012 critique of behavioral nudging was validated 14 years later in The New York Review of Books, which wrote behavioral-science experts were "at best the useful idiots of corporate interests"
Why it matters: an early signal of AI being used as a large-scale auditor of foundational academic literature, surfacing errors that had resisted correction for centuries.
More from AGI Musings
- Mustafa Suleyman and Yuval Harari discuss AI, consciousness and humanity — krishnan · 2026-11-23
- Riemann proof compiles in Lean but nobody understands it, and that counts — benno_krojer · 2026-11-23
- Polymarket: Only 10% odds US enacts AI safety bill by end of 2026 — Polymarket · 2026-11-23
- OpenAI Chief Scientist warns AI could spark 'avalanche' of breakthroughs by 2027 — Polymarket · 2026-11-23
- On AI and academia: we fund research for externalities, not to employ intellectual monks — shakoistsLog · 2026-11-23
- Solaris called the best depiction of encountering incomprehensible superintelligence — gautamcgoel · 2026-11-23