Riemann proof drama: Lean community certifies it, but a geometry predicate defined as constant True raises doubts
rickasaurus · x · 2026-11-23
The AI-assisted Riemann Hypothesis proof saga takes another turn:
- Community certification: After Alpöge released a 17M-line Lean library proof, the Lean and Mathlib communities issued a joint statement: all 175,187 modules compile, several independent kernels verified the 61GB proof export, and they state full confidence the proof is correct.
- New scrutiny: A critical paper found the anyGeometry geometry predicate is literally defined as fun => True — admitting everything — appearing across 24 files, meaning the geometry gate was effectively never enforced.
- Not settled yet: The source digger himself notes the key question remains unanswered: does the main theorem's dependency chain actually route through this predicate? If not, it's dead code in a corner of 170k files and the main theorem stands.
The takeaway for the AI-proof era: kernels can check every inference step, but not whether definitions live up to their names — machines check code, humans still have to read definitions line by line.
More from Fun
- Blogger woken at 3am by Neon-driven Gemini task results, gets hooked — TheTuringPost · 2026-11-23
- "Anthropic is giving Fabian Society": post-IPO Dario Amodei heads to Puglia — shakoistsLog · 2026-11-23
- Someone turned Gemini Neon praise into a full rap music video featuring tech CEOs — MatthewBerman · 2026-11-23
- POV: you have to babysit the NPC — a Resident Evil 4 escort meme — Mattapeh · 2026-11-23
- AI drops Goku into real life with convincing physics and lighting — heypearlai · 2026-11-23
- Meme: 'That was a REAL hypothesis you just proved' as AI bests mathematicians — shakoistsLog · 2026-11-23