Skeptic claims Alpöge's Lean "proof" of Riemann Hypothesis type-checks only via circular definitions
MickeySteamboat · x · 2026-11-23
X user MickeySteamboat raises a technical objection to the alleged Lean formalization of the Riemann Hypothesis by Alpöge: it type-checks only because the geometric side is definitionally identical to the analytic side — anyGeometry := fun => True, lattices are copies of the row data via rfl, and setDiv overwrites the height with the explicit formula (also rfl).
As a result, the inequality supposed to force zeros onto the critical line effectively compares a quantity with itself, meaning theorem riemannHypothesis holds trivially by construction rather than by proof. If accurate, passing the type checker says nothing about RH itself.
This is an unverified claim from a personal account, but it is a substantive technical accusation worth noting.
Related event: Doubts Mount Over Alpoge's Formalized Riemann Hypothesis Proof(2 posts)→
More from Research
- LingSante-3.1-air-VL tops medical imaging evals across derm, labs and X-rays — Dr_Alex_Crimi · 2026-11-23
- Mathematician praises Lean community's soundness work, admits skepticism is easier than building — mboehme_ · 2026-11-23
- New proposal: mandatory compute disclosures plus 15% capabilities cap could delay intelligence explosion a year — sjgadler · 2026-11-23
- Prune, train, upcycle: one model that scales with your RAM — minhnguyen · 2026-11-23
- Claude formalizes GRH proof approach in 17M lines of Lean, code checks out — elonmusk · 2026-11-23
- Training models to fill in omitted reasoning from proprietary model outputs: a FIM-style distillation idea — OwariDa · 2026-11-23