Gary Marcus: Alpöge's Claude-assisted Riemann proof took months of human guidance, not AI alone
GaryMarcus · x · 2026-11-23
Gary Marcus weighs in on Levent Alpöge's claimed proof of the Riemann Hypothesis (extending to the Generalized RH, with formalized arguments) developed in collaboration with Claude.
Key points:
- Social media widely misreads this as "AI solved RH alone." Marcus argues current AI could not have done it independently — it required months of deep guidance from Alpöge, an exceptional mathematician with AI expertise.
- As Christian Szegedy put it, Levent "made all the right (life) choices at the right time"; he didn't just prompt "Solve Riemann" — his shaping of the end product was considerable.
- It does not mean AGI has arrived; otherwise a human wouldn't have been needed to steer the process.
- The proof is 250,000 pages — hardly elegant — with no general lessons about doing math and no new techniques or concepts introduced so far.
- Marcus also asks why the news isn't immediately rescuing the market.
More from AGI Musings
- OpenAI chief scientist: losses below 0.8 unlocked emergent cybersecurity and math capabilities — kimmonismus · 2026-11-23
- Harari to Suleyman: 'If they are really gods, they will not remain your slaves' — PeterBowdenLive · 2026-11-23
- Two-person lab GSI claims 250+ breakthroughs across 8 fields with custom AI-built solvers, not brute-force compute — udmrzn · 2026-11-23
- iamtrask: Great writing is constrained by IP access, proofs only by compute — iamtrask · 2026-11-23
- Daniel Litt: the Lean-formalized Riemann proof is likely correct, no human understands it yet — littmath · 2026-11-23
- Physicist Anthony Aguirre publicly challenges AGI lab staff: you're building superintelligence that makes humans cognitively obsolete — michael_nielsen · 2026-11-23