The people who build and maintain Lean reviewed the full 17-million-line proof and confirmed on November 21 that it proves the real Riemann Hypothesis, with multiple independent checkers agreeing and no sneaked-in assumptions. On Jenny Nielsen's finding that one geometry function always returns True, the author concedes the code exists but argues a trivial 'always yes' stamp doesn't invalidate the result—generic pieces get carried along in such systems, and what matters is whether the hard work happens elsewhere in the chain.
MickeySteamboat · x · 2026-11-23
围绕「LLM 辅助生成的 1700 万行 Lean 证明是否真的证明了黎曼猜想」的争议,博主站队 Lean/Mathlib 专家一方:Lean 的实际维护者已于 11 月 21 日官方确认整个证明对应数学界标准形式的黎曼猜想,且未夹带额外假设,多个独立检查器结果一致。
针对 Jenny Nielsen 指出的「某几何函数被写成恒返回 True」的问题,博主承认该代码确实存在,但认为这不足以推翻最终结论:这类形式化系统中允许存在被顺带携带的平凡片段,关键在于真正的证明工作是否在别处完成。
Related event: Lean Community Officially Confirms Riemann Hypothesis Formal Proof(2 posts)→
More from Research
- Papers on AI timelines are growing super-exponentially, now doubling every 3.8 months — peterwildeford · 2026-11-23
- Unreleased frontier AI formalizes Fermat's Last Theorem proof, fells Millennium Problems, roils mathematicians — Afinetheorem · 2026-11-23
- Elliptic-curve discrete log already has a poly-time solution — and could an LLM have found it? — jamestagg · 2026-11-23
- P ≠ NP would not save cryptography: quantum and quantum-gravity computing are the real threat — jamestagg · 2026-11-23
- Poland's 9B-parameter Thalamus Reasoning tops LongevityBench, beating 29 models — Dr_Singularity · 2026-11-23
- Erik Hoel's Bicameral Labs proposes 'qualiaphobic' AI architectures provably hostile to consciousness theories — erikphoel · 2026-11-23