AI-assisted Riemann proof under fire as developer finds geometry check that always returns True
theshawwn · x · 2026-11-23
A developer investigating the Lean formalization of the AI-assisted Riemann Hypothesis (GRH) proof found that a key geometry check, anyGeometry, is defined as fun => True — returning True unconditionally.
- The function appears in 24 files and is used in code that builds the proof's assumptions
- A paper by Jenny Lorraine Nielsen argues the 175k-file archive's structural witnesses are vacuously true: content-extracting lemmas are never called, and the height equation holds only by rfl
- Lean's kernel verifies derivations against given definitions but cannot question whether those definitions carry the claimed mathematics
- It's not yet confirmed whether the final theorem actually depends on the always-True function; if so, the proof is invalid
More from Fun
- Dev builds a lights-control API and lets an AI watch his camera to auto-optimize lighting — TheZachMueller · 2026-11-23
- Vercel CTO jokes: half of Anthropic's revenue is Claude getting zsh word-splitting wrong — cramforce · 2026-11-23
- AI-generated anime video meme of Jensen Huang goes viral on Reddit — rising-hurricane · 2026-11-23
- AI commentator calls out flood of fake tweets impersonating Jensen Huang — bigaiguy · 2026-11-23
- Blogger who 'never has photos of himself' posts a set of strikingly realistic selfies, likely AI-generated — miniapeur · 2026-11-23
- Running inkling 2 mini on vLLM gets the Titanic band meme treatment — VoidAsuka · 2026-11-23