Optogenetics could have been invented in the 1970s — how common are biology's 'delayed inventions'?
NikoMcCarty · x · 2026-11-22
Niko McCarty explores biology's 'delayed inventions': the pieces for optogenetics — light-sensitive microbial ion channels — were known in the 1970s when Crick called for a light-based neural switch, yet the field emerged only in the early 2000s. Deisseroth himself acknowledged the solution was 'available in principle' before Crick articulated it. Citing Brian Potter's analysis of 190 inventions (stethoscopes and anesthetics could plausibly have arrived 1,000+ years earlier), and PCR's own decade-long delay (Kleppe sketched it in 1971), McCarty argues for better cross-field idea-bridging — which Ed Boyden calls 'involuntary collaboration' and which AI might accelerate. He's soliciting more examples for a piece he's writing.
More from AGI Musings
- V.E. Schwab: Writing is an art, publishing is a business — david_perell · 2026-11-22
- Asking basic questions in the AI era: don't let gaps feel like verdicts — brandongalang · 2026-11-22
- Claude predicts AI will crack math proofs, battery materials and abandoned drug candidates within 5 years — alex_verem · 2026-11-22
- Most math will never be proved: shortest proofs are astronomically long, says dev — LLMs don't change that — jfischoff · 2026-11-22
- Oxford's Toby Ord Pushes Back on Claims AI Gives Anthropic 10x Research Speedup — tobyordoxford · 2026-11-22
- X Blocking Claude Access Is One More Reason Not to Write Notes There — generativist · 2026-11-22