Comparative advantage won't save you: horses had it too, and still lost to AI

paraschopra · x · 2026-11-21

Paras Chopra points out a common misunderstanding of comparative advantage: it guarantees trade will always happen, but not prosperity — or even a living wage.

His example: even after cars were invented, horses had a comparative advantage, yet the price they commanded was so low it didn't cover their fodder.

This undercuts the optimistic claim that humans will always have comparative advantage and hence AI (or those controlling it) would want to trade with us: true, but prices are set by supply and demand — and that guarantees nothing.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →