Skeptic: Anthropic's RH formalization is 175,187 files of Monte Carlo, not a proof

basedjensen · x · 2026-11-21

Bob McElrath disputes Anthropic's claimed Riemann Hypothesis proof: the Lean formalization spans 175,187 files, which he calls a Monte Carlo exercise rather than a logical proof.

He has spent hours compiling the Lean repo on a beefy machine — so many files that AIs get confused. His assessment: no non-classical content, and no actual logical proof of RH. A key skeptical technical take on the AI-math claim of the day.

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →