The 'human vs AI math' debate revisits a generation-ship sci-fi story about class and dignity

teortaxesTex · x · 2026-11-21

The ongoing 'human vs AI math' discourse prompted the author to revisit a Western sci-fi short story about generation ships, contrasting it with how a Russian story handles the same 'FTL invented later' problem.

The shared excerpt describes a protocol where target planets are 'untouchable': only the original crews who paid with their lives and decades of travel may set foot there. Later-arriving FTL ships are forbidden from those stars. Contacted heroes get one private choice — return home to a new life or continue the mission — made individually to avoid peer pressure; those who stay have the offer erased from memory, and those who leave have their disappearance staged (e.g., simulated meteorite deaths) to preserve the mission's dignity. The author notes how much class hate runs through Western sci-fi.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →