RH formalization doubts deepen: Alpoge's proof witness also called bunk

Pseudomanifold · x · 2026-11-21

Skepticism over the recent Riemann Hypothesis formalization continues to mount. QualiaQuanta argues that Alpoge's proof is "also dead": the Anygeometry=true setting propagates to the witness, rendering it bunk.

This extends earlier criticism that key quantities in the formalization were defined "to make the inequalities hold" rather than obtained independently — making the argument potentially circular. Several math researchers, including Pseudomanifold, reposted the critique.

Related event: Doubts Mount Over Alpoge's Formalized Riemann Hypothesis Proof(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from Fun

Fun channel →