250,000-page Riemann proof is more like an iPhone than magic: the AI math comprehension debate
nptacek · x · 2026-11-21
Responding to discussion of the claimed Riemann Hypothesis proof, jonstokes offers a counterpoint: the new proof is more like an iPhone than a magical artifact defying human explanation.
- No single person understands everything in an iPhone, but many people understand parts of it, so civilization collectively grasps it in a vague sense
- AI-generated proofs will follow the same pattern: they'll arrive like products from a Shenzhen factory — we won't see the full picture, but can apprehend enough to judge their usefulness
- Mathematicians will collectively develop a vague grasp of such proofs, and it won't be weird — we'll get used to it
The quoted post by MattPirkowski argues for "Computational Reenchantment": the claimed proof runs 250,000+ pages, meaning even its human "author" doesn't comprehend it at full resolution. Since computational verification scales far faster than human comprehension, we'll increasingly use abstractions we understand less and less to do more and more.
More from AGI Musings
- Gary Marcus mocks 'AI psychosis' hype over AI-solved math problems with satirical test — GaryMarcus · 2026-11-21
- NYU/UT Austin study: all 9 frontier models write text harder to process than human writing — windx0303 · 2026-11-21
- After AI Cracked Navier–Stokes, Millennium Problems Fell Fast—Why Did Tao Miss It? — burny_tech · 2026-11-21
- Neuroscientists warn top journals are full of 'polished garbage' systems neuroscience papers — KordingLab · 2026-11-21
- Forecasters put 85% odds on AI solving another Millennium Problem by 2027 — NathanpmYoung · 2026-11-21
- Kurzweil's next book: 'The Singularity Came and Went' — PeterDiamandis · 2026-11-21