Gary Marcus open letter to OpenAI's Noam Brown: don't imply months-long o1 runs will yield cancer drugs or Riemann proofs

scaling01 · x · 2026-11-21

scaling01 reshares Gary Marcus's open letter to OpenAI's Noam Brown challenging the o1 scaling narrative. Marcus argues that suggesting future versions 'thinking for weeks' could produce a new cancer drug, battery breakthroughs, or a Riemann proof is unrealistic — candidates still need clinical and lab work, and o1 remains unreliable even at tic-tac-toe, sometimes no better than earlier models. Longer processing times, he argues, are unlikely to yield transcendent reasoning; the implied hype misleads many. Context: Brown's original tweet said o1 thinks for seconds now, with future versions aiming for hours to weeks of inference.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →