ChatGPT sides with friend in CDT prisoners-dilemma argument, author 'losing his mind'

jd_pressman · x · 2026-11-21

jdpressman jokes he's "losing his mind" after arguing with a friend over whether CDT still defects in a prisoners dilemma where cooperation and unilateral defection yield equal payoff — the friend says yes, and ChatGPT agrees with the friend. In the quoted reply, @jessicata counters with the standard definition: the utility ranking must be (cooperate, defect) < (both defect) < (both cooperate) < (defect, cooperate), and there's no "defecting first" in PD. A nerdy AI-circle spat over decision theory and LLM judgment.

Related event: CDT Prisoner's Dilemma Debate Sparks Suspected Google AI Hallucination(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →