ICLR 2027 desk-rejects paper over co-author's AI review policy violation

aran_nayebi · x · 2026-11-21

A first author reports their paper was desk-rejected at ICLR 2027 because a co-author allegedly violated the conference's AI policy for reviewers — with the decision arriving only after the two-week rebuttal period ended. Screenshots show the paper had received 4 official reviews (average 2.75). The author questions this collective punishment: co-authors have no practical way to prevent or detect a reciprocal reviewer using AI to write a review, so the policy is neither preventive nor properly targeted. Several AI/ML conferences have recently adopted similar desk-reject policies over reviewer AI misuse.

Related event: ICLR desk-rejects papers over co-authors' AI-written reviews(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from Safety

Safety channel →