Newton's Principia analogy warns Claude-style RH proofs may Goodhart math
julianboolean_ · x · 2026-11-21
Reflecting on Claude's Riemann Hypothesis result, the author invokes Terry Tao's concern about AIs Goodharting open problems.
Key thread:
- Did Claude discover new theory, or was RH already "within the convex hull" of existing ideas that humans simply weren't competent enough to combine?
- Newton's Principia analogy: the inverse-square orbit problem was technically solvable within Euclidean geometry — but only Newton could do it. Had Claude existed in the 1600s and solved it geometrically, we'd have declared victory while impeding the invention of calculus, a far more general tool;
- Historical echo: Leibniz's algebraic notation generalized better, and Continental mathematicians outpaced Newton-loyal Britain for a century;
- Conclusion: brute-forcing open problems may not be the best path for math; attention is finite and shrinking, "open problems" as a call to arms may cease to exist, and RH may be the last time solving a math problem is major news.
More from Research
- DatologyAI open-sources Zephon, a data loader with elastic determinism for LLM training — josh_wills · 2026-11-21
- Meta compression researcher Guangxuan Xiao says gradual pruning won't recover performance faster — teortaxesTex · 2026-11-21
- Real Cameras are Radiometric: new paper lifts any geometric camera model with aperture, focus surface, vignetting — ssh4net · 2026-11-21
- USC's Heave-Ho trains Unitree G1 humanoids to collaborate, scales 2 to 10 robots — CyberRobooo · 2026-11-21
- Kaomoji emotion probe validated: 0.68 correlation with valence direction, 0.79 when trained — Sauers_ · 2026-11-21
- PhysLDM reconstructs deformable trajectories at 2.48mm precision with 78x token compression — jiqizhixin · 2026-11-21