Herbie Bradley: 'superintelligence transforms the world' arguments are motte-and-bailey

sebkrier · x · 2026-11-21

Herbie Bradley argues that 'radically transform the world' superintelligence claims often use a motte-and-bailey: the defensible motte (things get crazy, disempowerment seems likely) vs. the much weaker bailey (AI overtakes humans at the frontier of science). He notes that 'AIs will be at least as good as humans at every intellectual task' is correct but doesn't decide between Boaz's vision and full disempowerment, and calls for serious writing making the case that 'humans not at the helm' is actually likely.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →