Turning 20 lung nodules into 3D shows radiologist outlines vary 1.49x

MaziyarPanahi · x · 2026-11-20

Maziyar Panahi converted four radiologists' outlines of the same 20 lung nodules into 3D and found size depends heavily on whose outline you take: median 1.49x volume difference across readers. One nodule spans 1,453–1,892 mm³ — by volume 3 radiologists say Lung-RADS 4A and 1 says 4B; by diameter all 4 say 4B; an open model lands in 4A. 5 of 20 nodules split like this, highlighting annotation consistency issues in medical AI evaluation.

Related event: Radiologists' Lung Nodule Segmentations Vary Up to 1.49x in Volume(3 posts)→

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →