Mathematicians push back on "convex hull" cope: LLMs already crossed the new-idea line
dioscuri · x · 2026-11-20
The debate over OpenAI's Navier–Stokes paper heats up. Scott Armstrong called criticism of it "pure nonsense," and Obhishek Saha agrees, arguing the "convex hull" theory of ideas (new ideas as mere recombination of old ones) is largely incoherent.
Reposter dioscuri adds: - The line between a genuinely new idea and recombination is arbitrary and subjective, reflecting the judge's taste more than the idea - However you draw it, LLMs have clearly crossed it - Without LLMs, no human would have proved the Navier–Stokes blowup, the quasi-Riemann hypothesis, pi's irrationality exponent being 2, or Unique Games in the coming years
More from AGI Musings
- AI can't replace developers: no coverage, no accountability, no expertise — gerardsans · 2026-11-20
- Dev's long-form rebuttal: scaling can't conjure consciousness, 'quantum woo' hijacks anti-AI wave — AndyMasley · 2026-11-20
- "AI Is a Text Sampler": Why LLMs Can't Own Decisions or Replace Accountability — gerardsans · 2026-11-20
- AI stocks down 53% in 5 months — faster than the dot-com crash, says Gary Marcus — GaryMarcus · 2026-11-20
- AI Answers Are Replacing Clicks, and the Open Web May Never Be the Same — DavidLinthicum · 2026-11-20
- Gary Marcus amps doubt: no evidence AI profits will shift to apps — GaryMarcus · 2026-11-20