Fixed-rule scan of 3,631 public MCP servers flags 24 as do-not-use

Minimum-Gift-5217 · reddit · 2026-11-20

The author of Faintprint ran its pure fixed-rule engine (no AI, no API key) over the tool lists of 3,631 public MCP servers (65,008 tools) published by the Smithery directory. Results: 24 servers (0.7%) rated do-not-use — 15 for passages telling the AI to hide its behavior from the user — plus 213 check-before-use and 907 not-finished; 2,484 showed no signs of attack.

They also disclose their own false-positive lesson: a rule matching credential-plus-send-instruction alone flagged 91 servers, but reading 74 of them showed all were sign-in docs; narrowing the rule to one sentence pointing at a web address cut it to 7. The authors stress these are rule flags, not measured attack counts, and no servers are named.

Original post →

More from coding & agent

coding & agent channel →