Philosophers clash over Nagel calling serious AI-consciousness debate "ridiculous"

rgblong · x · 2026-11-20

Consciousness researcher rgblong criticizes philosopher Thomas Nagel's public stance on AI consciousness: not for holding a low credence, but for repeatedly saying that even "taking the question seriously" is "ridiculous" — an attitude he argues is unwarranted.

Anil Seth replies that he shares the same credence direction but doesn't endorse Nagel's wording, distinguishing media-interview remarks from academic contributions. rgblong adds that the bar for such statements should be higher in media interviews, given their effect on public discourse around a high-stakes issue.

Related event: Philosopher Nagel criticized for dismissing AI consciousness debate(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →