A 6-model board for decisions: hide opinions, let Claude chair and adopt the sharpest argument

aryanXmahajan · x · 2026-11-20

A practical workflow for getting true second opinions from AI: query 6 models from 6 companies simultaneously, telling each it won't see the others and putting today's date at the top to prevent stale arguments. Then have Claude chair the review — not counting votes but comparing arguments, under the rule "follow the majority only if its reasoning holds; overrule it if a smaller group makes the sharper argument." The chair must show which objection changed its mind. In the author's first real call (picking an opening line for a giveaway), 4 models picked the safe option and 2 the bold one; Claude kept the strongest line and incorporated the one correct point from the losing side — one decision with the best losing argument built in, not 6 watered-down opinions.

Original post →

More from coding & agent

coding & agent channel →