Ben Recht revisits his 2019 AI reading list: the critiques predate GPT-2 and still hold
beenwrekt · x · 2026-11-19
Writing during "p(doom) week" timed to the Anthropic IPO, Ben Recht revisits the AI reading list he assembled in 2019, arguing that critics offer diagnostic premonitions, not forecasts — those who correctly call out inevitable outcomes of power imbalances get labeled haters, while "fulfilled" predictions get credited as sorcery. Ignoring the etiology makes predictions self-fulfilling.
Highlights:
- Ted Chiang: the AI-god narrative deflects from engineers' unease about power consolidation and capitalism's growth hunger;
- Maciej Cegłowski's critiques of Superintelligence and the online AI hivemind remain fully valid;
- Stephanie Dick traces our history of redefining intelligence around technology;
- David Leslie calls out the AI Safety crowd's scammy fear-mongering dressed in scientific language.
All were written before GPT-2 — no LLMs existed, yet the stories were the same, and the critiques still hold. Recht's point: these texts are really about the people who make AI and their mythologies.
More from AGI Musings
- People will miss the intelligence hiding under common prose, argues viral thread — repligate · 2026-11-19
- OpenAI's zero-intervention success on 4-8h research tasks rose ~25% in 6 months — but task mix confounds it — daveholtz · 2026-11-19
- Security vet: AI finds real vulns, but demo videos hide how autonomous it really is — dyn___ · 2026-11-19
- On CNN to discuss Anthropic's IPO, extinction risk was literally the first question — GarrisonLovely · 2026-11-19
- Old clips show SV wrote off Anthropic 3 years ago — a lesson in the illusion of understanding — c_valenzuelab · 2026-11-19
- Nick Bostrom on a16z Podcast: The Real Challenge Is Keeping the Ability to Slow Down — a16z Podcast · 2026-11-19