Researcher slams peer review: reviewers do a terrible job, chairs hide behind 'too many papers'

taiyasaki · x · 2026-11-19

A researcher—clarifying the complaint isn't about an ICLR rejection—publicly criticizes peer review: many reviewers do a terrible job, ACs and PCs hide behind the "too many papers" excuse, and rules of engagement are constantly violated with no consequences. The post adds to ongoing debate about declining review quality at top AI conferences.

Original post →

More from Companies & People

Companies & People channel →