Philosophers argue LLMs miss the point on consciousness: the common denominator is life, not language
erikphoel · x · 2026-11-19
In a thread riffing on Thomas Nagel's view of consciousness, dmdebruijn argues: bats, mice, foxes and cows all have consciousness — the subjective what-it-is-like of being them — yet none use language or generate video. So language patterning and video generation, without living a life in an environment, are a conceptual non-starter as grounds for consciousness.
He extends Nagel's point: you can't found fox consciousness on LLMs, since language use isn't there. Bifurcating the world into humans+LLMs (language) versus all other life looks in the wrong place — the far more plausible common denominator for consciousness is life itself, with all the stakes of organic living. A philosophical counter to the "LLMs are conscious" debate.
More from AGI Musings
- Ex-Anthropic researcher Jacob Coxon to protest outside former workplace on IPO day, calls for ban on 'AIs building better AIs' — Polymarket · 2026-11-19
- Caltech math professor stops grading homework because everyone uses AI — Distinct-Question-16 · 2026-11-19
- Economist Paul Novosad: game designers should build products that change us for the better — paulnovosad · 2026-11-19
- LATO raises $4.7M as its agents interview 29 experts in 5 days on Anthropic's $900B compute bet — annbordetsky · 2026-11-19
- Gary Marcus mocks market for spiking on news of another $100B into a company that may never profit — GaryMarcus · 2026-11-19
- The 90s vs 2026 husband meme capturing the AI companion shift — hey_abusiddik · 2026-11-19