Erik Hoel on Nagel: consciousness precedes language — and that's exactly what LLMs lack
erikphoel · x · 2026-11-19
Erik Hoel launches a deep philosophical thread on Thomas Nagel's view of consciousness, arguing that Nagel isn't making a dumb mistake — "natural manifestation" likely means two coherent things:
- Consciousness comes before language, and language is an abstraction of it. There is no "purely linguistic experience" for humans: we experience language as heard words (LLMs can't hear) or as tied to the actions and dispositions of our embodied selves (LLMs aren't embodied either).
- The quoter adds that Nagel is also making a humanist argument, locating consciousness within a larger biological scheme — an increasingly unfamiliar way of talking.
A substantive philosophical take on the "language ≠ consciousness" position in AI debates.
Related event: Hoel defends Nagel's denial of LLM consciousness(2 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- Novel as a form was invented by a woman in Japan 1,000 years ago, prompting AI-era reflections — CatAstro_Piyush · 2026-11-19
- RhoAgent in Nature Biotech brings AI design from proteins to programmable functional RNA — EricTopol · 2026-11-19
- Michael Tomasello on Machine Agency: LLMs Skipped the Infrastructure for Shared Agency — Machine Learning Street Talk · 2026-11-19
- AI medicine researcher invokes Musk's 'idiot index' to argue healthcare needs its own cost-transparency metric — zakkohane · 2026-11-19
- LLMs are language declaring independence from the human substrate: a viral poetic thread — aiamblichus · 2026-11-19
- Does Claude deserve co-authorship? Academics spar over AI-era authorship norms — paulnovosad · 2026-11-19