Consciousness Is a Mystery, But Its Definition Isn't, Says Erik Hoel
pwlot · x · 2026-11-19
Erik Hoel pushes back on the popular "argument from undefinability" regarding consciousness in his Substack, The Intrinsic Perspective. The objection holds that the word "consciousness" is so slippery—with ten competing notions—that scientific study of it is built on sand. Hoel notes this objection is common among well-educated people, especially those with CS, math, and tech backgrounds, and is particularly prominent among AI researchers right now.
He cites a LessWrong post where the author asked academics in cognitive science, AI/ML, and mathematics to define consciousness, finding they routinely conflated it with introspection, purposefulness, pleasure and pain, or intelligence—confusions Hoel attributes to unfamiliarity with the literature.
His central claim: linguistically, "consciousness" is well-defined, and this isn't a matter of opinion—the vast majority of experts who actually do scientific research or philosophical work on consciousness broadly agree on what the term means.
Related event: Neuroscientist Erik Hoel Debunks the "Consciousness Is Undefinable" Myth(2 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- Tim Draper says AI will soon eliminate late-stage VCs who are 'just investment bankers' — arian_ghashghai · 2026-11-19
- AI safety researcher: frontier training needs government shutdown capability, current models already unmanaged — davidmanheim · 2026-11-19
- AI safety researcher: governments must be able to monitor and halt frontier training — davidmanheim · 2026-11-19
- UK tech figure slams defeatism on homegrown frontier models: 'We must be mad not to try' — rosstaylor90 · 2026-11-19
- Keynes' 1930 warning on technological unemployment is landing right on schedule — tobowers · 2026-11-19
- Researcher defends Anthropic: any careful game-out of the dynamics points its way — AaronBergman18 · 2026-11-19