Erik Hoel: philosopher Nagel's denial of LLM consciousness isn't an obvious mistake
erikphoel · x · 2026-11-19
Erik Hoel argues that Thomas Nagel—arguably the best living philosopher—isn't making an obvious mistake in denying LLM consciousness. Nagel's notion of "natural manifestation" likely means two coherent things: (1) consciousness precedes language, which is an abstraction of it; (2) there's no "purely linguistic experience" for humans—language manifests as heard words or through one's embodied self, and LLMs can neither hear nor have embodiment.
More from AGI Musings
- OpenAI report: researcher AI use rising exponentially, labs should disclose RSI indicators — NinaDSchick · 2026-11-19
- Philosopher Thomas Nagel singles out Anthropic's approach to AI as 'abominable' — GaryMarcus · 2026-11-19
- Zvi's AI #195: Anthropic IPO day, Claude Fable 5.2 vs GPT-6.2, Google's new models — TheZvi · 2026-11-19
- Bob McGrew: Superintelligence Needs the Physical World — the Hard Takeoff Is Wrong — No Priors · 2026-11-19
- Zvi's AI #195: Anthropic IPO day, Fable 5.2 vs GPT-6.2, and rising acceleration worries — Don't Worry About the Vase (Zvi) · 2026-11-19
- Bob McGrew on No Priors: superintelligence needs the physical world, hard takeoff is wrong — No Priors · 2026-11-19